A number of years ago a collection
of
essays recommended that Christians
seriously consider the option of not voting. I am revisiting these essays. My recommendation had been that the Church vote, but do so in a uniquely Christian way. When a follower of
Jesus votes for a political candidate (whether it be a Democrat, a Republican,
or an Independent), I argued, it should be
as an
act of witness.
This vote
as witness needed clarification, for in various
ways the “witnessing vote” was a reticent vote.
It could never be a decision as to which
candidate the voter can endorse one hundred percent.
Now the situation is such that I am wondering whether or not I can vote at all in the presidential election. I am wondering if fidelity to "votng as witness" now means not voting.
It is true that the believer ought
to confess that every politician and every political system on this side of the
new creation is flawed and tainted. So where the Christian can
vote in good conscience, he or she cannot cast an unreserved vote; this, too, would
equal being taken captive by the powers. By its very nature this reserved voting is a witness to “better
things,” to the “world to come,” which the New Testament
promises. But sometimes
the political situation has decayed to the point where just voting would be
evidence of being taken captive by the powers. Are we facing such a situation in 2016? The question should at least be asked.
The vote as witness, where possible, needed to be
a qualified vote because the Christian was only voting for that which could be faithfully
celebrated in the candidate’s character and platform (not for the entire character
and platform). Part of his or her witness was to make this clear: in
acknowledging the candidate’s or the party’s flaws, the Christian bore witness
to the broken human condition. But what if the character is so flawed, and so unChristian, that there is little left to celebrate? How can we vote for a person who claims to represent Christians, but exhibits the spirit of an antichrist? Do we take the mark of the beast?
I have admitted, in the past, that voting "as witness" was a difficult way
to vote, for the voter’s reticence was not directly reflected in the ballot
count. What made the voting reticent was mostly an acknowledgement in the
believer’s own mind that the “vote” was just a vote, and not a “bowing of the
knee.” This reticence was first
known in the Christian’s own heart, and that mattered immensely. At the public
level, it demanded that the believer actively participate in grassroots
political conversation to make this “witnessing vote” clear. But more
importantly it demanded that the Christian’s whole life reflect a message of
political reservation. His or her vote was counter-intuitive to the usual way of politics:
it could never be triumphant (no pun intended!). But perhaps today such political reservation must lead us to NOT vote for a presidential candidate at all, but focus instead on other political activity, where one's conscience is not sold out.
So the restrained way in which a
Christian votes, or now does not vote, is still both a witness to the political system’s imperfection and a
witness to God’s impending righteous reign. Such reticent about voting is a witness
because its very standoffishness speaks of confidence in another citizenship,
in another sovereign. The Church’s hope ultimately lies in a different Candidate-Elect! He is the only one who can fully bring
justice and peace to a broken world.
While the Christian takes seriously
his or her vote, or now the decision not to vote, its significance is not to be exaggerated. This would betray
the witness. More important than the “vote” is the Spirit’s bringing of the kingdom,
however provisionally and proleptically, through the mission of the Church. So
the Christian intentionally, and in the community of faith, seeks other and
better ways of concretely modeling kingdom life, of manifesting in seed form
the culture of the world to come. The Church’s “vote (or no vote) as witness” proclaims that
she still waits for the kingdom whose builder and maker is God.
Such an orientation of voting as witness leads the
Christian to a unique set of criteria for voting. For example, the criteria we use to make a
judgment about mildly better or worse consequence must be in terms of God's
special provision for the poor and oppressed.
That is, our criteria are not fundamentally about what will make my life
better or America stronger or protect the middle class, but which policies are
more or less likely to provide some measure of care for those who are unable to
care for themselves. Determining the consequences of a vote can be notoriously
difficult; but the criteria are clear. Today the very emphasis on "making America great again" is totally out of step with these criteria.
There is a final “witness” inherent
in the Christian’s voting practice: he or she votes, or does not vote, deliberately and
intentionally, but also penitently, bearing witness to his or her own finite
and fallen condition – and likely failure of good judgment. The Christian
must vote or decide not to vote; the Christian in so doing acts, and faithfully participates in what ways he or she can in the political process. All the while the Church should bear witness to
the grace that heals society’s sickness (even the political one) and atones for
people’s sin (even the sin of a poorly cast ballot; or the potential sin of refraining from casting a ballot at all). So the Christian acts,
believing that God may be pleased to use his or her humble act of faith to make
a difference for good. The Church’s “vote as witness” points to the coming
Kingdom of Christ, but it also acts responsibly to make a difference now, whether by actually voting, or by withholding a vote.
When the believer can
in good conscience participate in the political process, he or she votes to
bear witness to God’s grace and to the full hope that can finally and only be
found in the good news of Jesus Christ. And when the time is such, that any vote would deny the gospel, the believer does not vote, and in that way still bears witness to the Lord of all the earth.